Re: HEC News: Deadly Rite of Passage

From: Corita Fischer (cfischer@D.UMN.EDU)
Date: Mon Jan 24 2000 - 15:52:28 EST

  • Next message: Robert J. Chapman, Ph.D.: "A thoughtful message"

    Yes, you are right that the lay person reads these comments and sees
    "all" or "most" college students. Isn't that sad, because I maintain
    the article was pretty good if we went back and changed all the
    references to binge drinking to high risk drinking and made sure the
    public reads
    " some" students.

     I think we have to be careful to not swing the pendulum the other
    way--some students are dying, some students are suffering extreme
    consequences-relationships, grades etc. Even though the statistics may
    be improving in some schools, the statistics are still too high. We
    don't want to sensationalize the problem; on the other hand, there is a
    problem and we need to address it. High Risk drinking is common in
    college, is it not? I think this writer was trying to address the issue
    and it is our own industry's fault that does not get rid of the term
    "binge drinking.'" After all, Harvard-who gets published on this issue
    every year in the press-refuses to change the term on their surveys. I
    am as frustrated as you are about this term--but I guess we have to
    still keep educating. How can we do that on a large scale, however,
    when those of us in the education field cannot agree on a term across
    the board.? Frustrations, frustrations.....

    Thanks for your comments,
    Corey

    _____________________________________________________________________
    Corita (Corey) Fischer
    Health Education/UMD Health Services
    University of Minnesota Duluth
    815 E. University Circle
    Duluth, Minnesota 55812
    Phone:218-726-7058
    Fax: 218-726-6132
    cfischer@d.umn.edu



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Jan 24 2000 - 15:54:47 EST